Saturday, November 21, 2026

Middle East Report - James M. Dorsey - Nov 21,2026 - Middle East Report James M. Dorsey

 

James discusses on this week’s Middle East Report on Radio Islam, Iran’s effort to force US President Donald Trump to choose between negotiations and war, the risk of the Iran war fuelling sectarianism, Israel’s troubled efforts to polish its tarnished image and repair relations with Democrats in the US Congress, and Saudi Arabia’s bad options in Yemen.

The Turbulent World with James M. Dorsey is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Transcript

[Anchor] Yes, James M. Dorsey is an award-winning scholar and journalist with a different perspective on the Middle East and a senior fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies at Singapore. James, thank you very much for your time and welcome to Radio Islam International.

[James M. Dorsey] Good morning, great to be with you on this Friday morning.

[Anchor] Thank you for joining us, James. So, Iran is forcing US President Donald Trump to choose between negotiating on Iranian terms or returning to an all-out war with its stepped-up attacks on shipping in the Strait of Hormuz and strikes against the US military facilities in Bahrain and Kuwait.

[James M. Dorsey] Indeed, Iran wants to force US President Donald Trump’s hand. The choice Iran is presenting to Trump is accept the Islamic Republic’s conditions for a ceasefire or return to all-out war. Iran’s calculus is clear.

It can’t allow Trump’s economic strangulation with the naval blockade of Iranian ports and sanctions on oil exports to continue indefinitely. That would be a slow death and makes all-out war a better option. With Iran striking US military facilities in Gulf states and stepping up attacks on shipping in the Strait of Hormuz, Trump is likely to make his choice in the coming days.

Now that his trilateral summit with the Chinese and Russian presidents is behind him and he is back in the United States. Some analysts suggest Trump has one alternative way out of his dilemma. Quietly let Iran export oil from its blockaded ports without any formal announcement.

The question is whether that would be good enough for Iran. Many in Iran smell victory with Iran’s strategy of inflicting pain on American consumers with rising energy prices and inflation having contributed to Republican losses in this month’s US congressional elections and Democrats taking control of Congress in January.

[Anchor] Yeah. So the longer the Gulf War continues, the more interest deepening sectarian divides in the Gulf.

[James M. Dorsey] The Iranian strikes at US military facilities in Bahrain and Kuwait may be about more than retaliation for US moves in Iran and the Gulf. Yes, they are about breaking the stalemate in the Strait of Hormuz. But Bahrain and Kuwait, rather than other Gulf states, may have also been targets because of their crackdowns on Shiite communities.

Bahrain, a Shiite majority country ruled by a Sunni Muslim minority that hosts the US Fifth Fleet, recently sentenced more than 60 Shiites, mostly clerics, to life in prison on charges of forming a terrorist organisation to overthrow the country’s constitutional monarchy, promoting Iran’s doctrine of Wilayat al-Faqih, or Guardianship of the Jurist, and or opposition to the Gulf state’s diplomatic relations with Israel.

Similarly, a Kuwaiti court last month sentenced a Shiite cleric and two others to death in absentia on charges of spying for Iran, joining Lebanon’s Hezbollah, and planning to assassinate senior government officials. The question is whether Iran will also target the United Arab Emirates after authorities recently detained five non-Emirati Shiite residents. Iran has exempted the UAE in recent months from its retaliatory strikes.

The convictions and arrests, as well as sectarian undertones in Saudi anti-Houthi rhetoric, raise the spectre of the conflict with Iran taking on a sectarian character. Scholars caution that the targeting of Shiites risks painting Shiite communities in the Gulf with a broad brush as an Iranian fifth wheel, rather than recognising the community’s diversity and complex relationship with the Islamic Republic.

[Anchor] Israel faces scrutiny over Gaza as Democrats take control of the U.S. Congress.

[James M. Dorsey] Israeli hopes that a post-Netanyahu government will help the Jewish state improve its severely damaged image and improve relations with a Democrat-controlled U.S. Congress threaten to get off to a troubled start. In what could be a bruising battle, Democrats are gearing up to block funding for Trump’s toothless Board of Peace and take Israel to task for failing to allow the entry of temporary housing materials and other humanitarian goods on a large scale into the Gaza Strip. The board is charged with implementing Trump’s 20-point Gaza peace plan.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has systematically prevented the board from operating in Gaza with up to 70 percent of the territory of the Strip occupied by Israel. Israel has refused to allow a United Nations Security Council-endorsed international stabilisation force to take control of the 30 percent of Gaza that is not directly occupied by Israel, as long as Hamas has not disarmed. The same is true for the National Committee for the Administration of Gaza, made up of Palestinian technocrats, that is supposed to assume responsibility for managing the Strip’s day-to-day affairs.

Hamas has said it would hand over Gaza’s civilian administration to the committee. With Israeli tanks operating beyond the yellow line that demarcates Israeli-occupied territory in violation of the ceasefire, a post-Netanyahu government will have to be more cooperative with the board if Israel wants to have a chance to improve its image and relations.

[Anchor] Finally, James, military advances by Yemen’s Houthis put Saudi Arabia between a rock and a hard place.

[James M. Dorsey] As we look at the last month or two of the fighting, the Houthis have been advancing militarily. They are besieging Taiz, Yemen’s third largest city, and moving on Aden, the seat of the Saudi-backed internationally recognised Yemeni government. The move strengthened the Houthis’ bargaining position if and when the warring parties returned to the negotiating table and leave the Saudis with no good options.

Addressing the structural problems of the Yemeni government’s forces that have put them on the back foot cannot be achieved overnight. It will take time. Moreover, defeating the Houthis, if at all possible, would require putting Saudi boots on the ground, something Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman is not willing to do.

Relying on air support for the Yemeni government forces isn’t doing the trick and won’t do the trick, given that Yemen, like Afghanistan, is mountainous terrain. Moreover, there are limits to what Saudi Arabia’s allies, including Turkey and Pakistan and its partners in a mutual defence agreement, are willing to do. They are willing to defend the kingdom with troops in Saudi Arabia, air defence, logistics, and intelligence sharing, but they refuse to get involved in fighting in Yemen itself.

[Anchor] Thank you very much for your time this morning. Much appreciated. Thank you for having me.

[James M. Dorsey] Have a good weekend. You too. Bye-bye.


No comments:

Post a Comment