Today's WorldView: Trump arrested; Macron in China; Finland in NATO
The Washington Post
Today's WorldView
By Ishaan Tharoor with Sammy Westfall
Macron and Europe hedge their bets on China
French President Emmanuel Macron and European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen in Paris on April 3. (Nathan Laine/Bloomberg News)
French President Emmanuel Macron and European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen in Paris on April 3. (Nathan Laine/Bloomberg News)
A curious geopolitical conjunction will take place this week. On the same day Speaker of the House Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) meets Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen in California, French President Emmanuel Macron is set to land in China on a major three-day tour of the country and meetings with Chinese President Xi Jinping.
The parallel encounters offer a snapshot of the West’s yin and yang over China: On one hand, a hardening hawkishness toward Beijing’s one-party regime, rooted in distrust of its ambitions and intentions; on the other, a recognition of the need to engage and maintain partnerships with the rising Asian superpower and economic titan, no matter the political atmosphere.
Macron goes to China on a complicated mission, keen to enlist Xi in the pursuit of checking Russia’s invasion of Ukraine while hoping to expand and boost ties on the economic front. Macron is also going in force, joined by both his finance and foreign ministers as well as a delegation of more than 50 business leaders from prominent French companies, including nuclear energy group EDF and aviation juggernaut Airbus. The trip includes stops both in Beijing and the southern metropolis of Guangzhou; Xi is expected to accompany Macron to Guangzhou, giving the two leaders many hours of potential time together for frank discussion.
The French president’s visit to China comes in the wake of recent missions by German Chancellor Olaf Scholz and Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez, who last week urged Xi to reach out to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky. Macron is expected to make a similar pitch, reinforced all the more by the presence of European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen, who conferred Monday in Paris with Macron, had a call Tuesday with Zelensky and will journey to China alongside the French president.
Top on the agenda is the war in Ukraine. Macron may have failed in his efforts to dissuade Russian President Vladimir Putin from carrying out his invasion last year, but, along with other Western European leaders, he believes Beijing may have the ability to curb Russia’s worst instincts, from deployment of nuclear weapons to its abuses of Ukrainian civilians.
“We won’t fundamentally change their position, but we expect that it could be possible that [the Chinese] don’t lean more toward Moscow,” a French official, speaking on the condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to talk to media, told me. “It is clear that China is one of the few countries in the world, if not the only country in the world, to be able to have a game-changing effect on the conflict, in either direction.”
Macron last visited China in 2019, before the coronavirus pandemic shut down the world and hastened the emergence of a more hardened, nationalist Beijing under Xi. “The president is coming to say, more than three years after his last trip: ‘Let’s hear where you are, and listen to us on where we are,’” the French official said. “This can have an impact.”
Europe’s stance on China has also shifted, with governments more wary of its intentions than in the past. The war in Ukraine sealed the collapse of Beijing’s so-called 17+1 diplomatic track with Eastern European countries, a mechanism that at one point was seen as a potential wedge within Europe. Last week, von der Leyen delivered a more hawkish speech on the E.U.’s future China policy, emphasizing the need to “de-risk” the continent’s exposure to the Chinese economy.
That presents an inherent tension with the other major component of Macron’s visit, some analysts argue. Von der Leyen “dismissed in her speech the idea that Xi could be counted on to play a constructive role in the Ukraine conflict and pushed for a de-risking of Europe’s economic relationship with China,” observed Noah Barkin of the German Marshall Fund of the United States. “Paris sees it differently. French officials close to Macron have indicated in recent weeks that he is considering offering Xi a deal along the lines of this: France will resist U.S. pressure to decouple from China if Beijing invests diplomatic capital in bringing about peace in Ukraine.”
Some European officials, especially those more animated by the threat posed by Russia, looked on skeptically at Macron and von der Leyen’s trip. “Preaching de-risking while marching ahead with business-as-usual is not an option,” tweeted Lithuanian foreign minister Gabrielius Landsbergis. “Surely we have learnt that increasing dependencies on totalitarian states weakens us as we discard the principles that made us strong.”
On a certain level, money talks — and the influence of the mammoth Chinese market shadows all global politics. “With Macron, this business delegation, it’s definitely a signal towards Beijing that economic cooperation is still very high on the agenda in Paris, but also at the level of the E.U. as a whole,” Alicja Bachulska, a policy fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations, told Euronews, suggesting that Europe was not on board with U.S.-led plans to isolate China and retrench Western companies away from certain sectors of the Chinese economy. “And this was visible in von der Leyen’s speech — Europe is not about decoupling, this American-style decoupling.”
The French official argued that the gap between U.S. and European positions on China was not as big as it may seem — or as the hawkish rhetoric in Washington, especially in Congress, may suggest. Biden administration officials had hoped to lower the temperatures and establish a more productive dialogue with their Chinese counterparts before the appearance of a Chinese spy balloon over the U.S. mainland inflamed Washington’s already heated conversation on China and compelled Secretary of State Antony Blinken to cancel a planned trip to Beijing.
Few in Washington are placing much stock on Macron being able to move the needle on the conflict in Ukraine through his discussions with Xi. But Europeans, at the same time, recognize that wholly yoking their policies and agendas to the grand strategy of the United States is a non-starter, even at a time when U.S. leadership has been crucial to anchoring a united transatlantic defense of Ukraine. They see the volatile dramas of U.S. politics, remember the disconcerting disruptions posed by former president Donald Trump and lament the prospect of his return.
“If Trump were really history, many in Europe would have fewer sleepless nights,” said Wolfgang Ischinger, a former German ambassador to the United States and a doyen of the continent’s foreign policy establishment, to the New York Times. “But the fundamental fear Trump provoked six years ago would not disappear.”
“What if the isolationist virus Trump unleashed continued to infect other candidates?” Ischinger added. “What if, instead of Trump, Republicans nominate another isolationist candidate for the presidency? And what if that candidate wins?”
“Macron has been consistent that we need to have a sovereign Europe,” the French official told me. “This is not to say that we would be in the middle between the United States and China. But we know that it is in our interests to be able to protect the interests of our citizens and not to always rely on others.”
1,000 Words
A Palestinian woman sits near Israeli border policemen in the Al-Aqsa compound on April 5. (Ammar Awad/Reuters)
A Palestinian woman sits near Israeli border policemen in the Al-Aqsa compound on April 5. (Ammar Awad/Reuters)
At least half a dozen people were injured after Israeli police raided the compound of the al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem’s old city, in an operation described by law enforcement as a response to rioting.
The incident further heightens tensions during a time of growing political upheaval and violence just as the Muslim holy month of Ramadan coincides with the Jewish Passover holiday. Far-right Jewish activists have threatened to slaughter a lamb in the mosque’s compound in a provocation supported by extremist members of Netanyahu’s government.
Talking Points
• Finland joined NATO as its 31st member on Tuesday, transforming Europe’s security landscape and doubling Russia’s border with NATO. Today’s Worldview’s Adam Taylor and my colleague Mikhail Klimentov break down why Finland – but not Sweden – is now in NATO.
• The Biden administration pledged to commit another $2.6 billion in military aid to Ukraine, saying it will provide additional air defense systems that include gun trucks and laser-guided weapons to counter Russia’s relentless use of drones.
• Elliott Broidy, a former top Republican fundraiser who admitted to illegally lobbying the Trump administration on behalf of foreign nationals, described his actions publicly for the first time. He testified in court about his failed attempts to quash a federal investigation of a Malaysian financier and to spur U.S. officials to extradite a wealthy Chinese dissident living in New York.
Top of The Post
Former president Donald Trump pleads not guilty to 34 felony counts
By Shayna Jacobs, Dylan Wells, David Nakamura and Jacqueline Alemany ● Read more »
Here are the 34 charges against Trump and what they mean
By Ann E. Marimow ● Read more »
ANALYSIS
Five takeaways from the Trump indictment in New York
By Philip Bump ● Read more »
Viewpoints
She was 19 when the atomic bomb dropped
By André Hörmann and Anna Samo | The New York Times ● Read more »
Why Italy’s far-right government is now ramping up WWII revisionism and fascist nostalgia
By Ariel David | Haaretz ● Read more »
No fake election can disguise the violence and repression in Myanmar
By The Washington Post Editorial Board ● Read more »
Newest member
Military personnel prepare to raise Finland’s flag during a ceremony Tuesday at NATO headquarters in Brussels. (Geert Vanden Wijngaert/AP)
Military personnel prepare to raise Finland’s flag during a ceremony Tuesday at NATO headquarters in Brussels. (Geert Vanden Wijngaert/AP)
BRUSSELS — Finland formally joined the North Atlantic Treaty Organization on Tuesday, a historic shift for a country that once insisted it was safer outside the military alliance and a sign of how Russian President Vladimir Putin’s gamble in Ukraine is upending the post-Cold War order.
Finnish membership will double NATO’s land border with Russia, adding more than 800 miles. It will also bolster the alliance’s presence around the Baltic Sea and enhance its position in the Arctic.
To justify his unprovoked attack on Ukraine, Putin cited the possibility of NATO expansion. Now, his war has brought a bigger, stronger NATO to his door.
“I am tempted to say, maybe this is the one thing that we can thank Mr. Putin for,” U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken said in Brussels on Tuesday.
Russia’s response on Tuesday was muted.
“We will be watching closely what is going on in Finland, how the NATO alliance will use Finnish territory in terms of deploying weapons, systems and infrastructure there, which will be close to our borders and therefore threaten us,” Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said in his daily briefing to journalists. “Depending on this, measures will be taken.”
Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said, “Perhaps I can describe the current condition of our relations by one word: a wreck,” he said. “Relations are ruined, and the United States is responsible for that.”
NATO officials and diplomats downplayed the threat of significant Russian retaliation, noting Moscow’s cautious response to Finland’s bid, as well as the fact that its forces are tied up in Ukraine. Experts say the addition of Finland, which like Sweden punches above its weight in terms of military might, represents an enhancement of overall NATO security, despite the alliance’s responsibility to defend the new member if required.
Finland’s membership became official on Tuesday with a transfer of papers at NATO’s Brussels headquarters. The Finnish flag was raised outside. “Joining NATO is good for Finland, good for Nordic security and good for NATO as a whole," Stoltenberg said.
But the fact that Sweden’s flag did not go up alongside Finland’s spoke to the challenge of keeping NATO allies united, even in the face of Russia’s threats.
Finland and Sweden applied for membership on the same day last spring. Putin’s aggression in Ukraine convinced both countries of the need to abandon their stance of military nonalignment. And they assessed that joining NATO in tandem, as quickly as possible, would be the best way to shield themselves from Russian retaliation.
But membership applications must be approved by all existing NATO countries. And Turkey positioned itself as a spoiler, with President Recep Tayyip Erdogan using the process to extract concessions and score domestic political points. Although he ultimately came around on Finland, he has continued to hold out on Sweden, citing Stockholm’s refusal to extradite those he calls “terrorists” affiliated with the militant Kurdistan Workers’ Party, or PKK.
Hungary is stalling, too.
NATO officials and diplomats express confidence that both member states will eventually back down. But it is not clear how soon that might happen. There is concern across the alliance that Turkey and Hungary have been willing to hand a symbolic victory to Russia — and that the rest of NATO has not been able to stop them. – Emily Rauhala and Missy Ryan
Read more: Finland joins NATO, doubling alliance’s land border with Russia
We think you’ll like this newsletter
Check out Fact Checker for a weekly review of what's true, false or in-between in politics, from The Post's famous fact-checking team. Count the pinocchios! Sign up »
No comments:
Post a Comment