Friday, May 15, 2026

SCMP Editorıal (kısmen) + China-US summit ‘remarkable’ but is it enough to change relations? (kısmen) + Opinion Dong Lei With the US, China must choose constructive power over destruction

 Opinion


Xi-Trump summit in Beijing heralds start of constructive, stable relations

Children greet Chinese President Xi Jinping and Donald Trump at the welcome ceremony for the US president outside the Great Hall of the People prior to their talks in Beijing, China, on May 14. Photo: Xinhua
Editorials represent the views of the South China Morning Post on the issues of the day.
Day one of the summit in Beijing between President Xi Jinping and US President Donald Trump opened with a welcome ceremony befitting the importance of the event, and ended with a significant agreement on the future of the China-US relationship. Most importantly, the two sides have agreed to establish a new strategic framework of “constructive strategic stability”.

This hopefully will define the bilateral relationship for the rest of Trump’s term. It is not simply the definition of a relationship between partners or rivals, however, but a realisation that the China-US relationship is so complex and consequential they need to keep it stable – not only for the sake of the two peoples, but also for the international community.

This will require the two sides to proactively manage the relationship. China realises there is bound to be competition and differences. But no rivalry should override the importance of an enduring stability between the two, given it is the base of the development of not only China and the US, but the whole world.

China-US summit ‘remarkable’ but is it enough to change relations?

The Xi-Trump summit is important but is unlikely to be enough to arrest the general decline in China-US ties, according to an analyst. Photo: Reuters
Dewey Simin Beijing
The US-China summit is “extremely important” to arrest the downward spiral of relations between the two countries, according to Li Cheng, a leading Chinese academic.
But a summit would not be enough to change the overall structure of ties, which had been fraught for years, Li said on Thursday as US President Donald Trump began the first full day of his state visit to Beijing – the first by an American leader since 2017.

The two presidents began the day with two hours of talks at the Great Hall of the People, where Chinese leader Xi Jinping urged the two countries to be “partners, not rivals”.

Dong Lei
Opinion

With the US, China must choose constructive power over destruction

China needs the global system to succeed. So it must not get entangled with Iran nor jeopardise US relations over Taiwan

US President Donald Trump greets Chinese President Xi Jinping at Gimhae Air Base on October 30, 2025 in Busan, South Korea. Photo: Getty Images
Dong Lei is an independent observer of Chinese politics and history, with a particular interest in China’s evolving role in global affairs.

Foreign affairs are not a series of disconnected episodes. They are a test of whether nations learn from history and act with foresight. The United States has often failed that test. It forgets that unchecked aggression leads to wider wars and that removing governments without building new authority invites chaos.

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Iran’s destabilising role in the Middle East and the collapse of Libya and Afghanistan all testify to what happens when those lessons are ignored.
China, by contrast, has not waged wars of conquest or slaughtered civilians abroad. Its rise has lifted hundreds of millions out of poverty and reshaped trade. Yet Beijing’s sharp focus on Taiwan, while understandable from its perspective, risks narrowing its vision. China still depends on the global trading system.

That system requires stability, and stability requires accommodation with the US, however pushy Washington may seem.

Iran is a case in point. Beijing has not actively helped Tehran prolong conflict, though it is pushing back against US sanctions over Iranian oil. Active help would entangle China in the very kind of destructive adventurism it has so far avoided. The world needs China to be a constructive power, not a spoiler. If China wants its prosperity to endure, it must resist the temptation in some quarters to side with those who thrive on chaos.
Iran’s partnership with Russia in Syria and support for militias across the region have created humanitarian disasters. China’s credibility as a responsible global actor would be undermined if it lent cover to such behaviour.
China’s permanent representative to the United Nations, Fu Cong, vetoes a UN Security Council draft resolution aiming to boost security in the Strait of Hormuz at the UN headquarters in New York on April 7. Photo: Xinhua
China’s permanent representative to the United Nations, Fu Cong, vetoes a UN Security Council draft resolution aiming to boost security in the Strait of Hormuz at the UN headquarters in New York on April 7. Photo: Xinhua
The US, for its part, must also avoid repeating mistakes. Barack Obama’s retreat from his red line on chemical weapons in Syria, Donald Trump’s embrace of Russian leader Vladimir Putin’s word over American intelligence and Joe Biden’s chaotic exit from Afghanistan all show how forgetting history leads to instability. The lesson is clear: hostility alone is not a policy. The US must rein in Russia and Iran but also find ways to work constructively with China.
Since the 1972 Shanghai Communique, the Taiwan issue has been managed without war. That fragile peace should not be jeopardised by missteps or grandstanding. The executive branch of the US government must lead with clarity, and China must recognise its own success is tied to a functioning global system.

China’s rise has brought undeniable benefits. It has lifted millions out of poverty, contributed to global supply chains and become a hub for manufacturing and innovation. But prosperity is not self-sustaining. It depends on rules, trust and the willingness of nations to accommodate each other’s interests.

Beijing may feel its accomplishments have not been fully appreciated, but resentment, if any, is not a strategy. The global trading system is the foundation of China’s success, and it would not survive should major powers treat it as expendable.

The future – whether in science, medicine or energy – depends on peace. China has a stake in that world. It should act accordingly. The alternative is a slide into confrontation, where Beijing’s focus on Taiwan blinds it to the broader risks of aligning with destabilisers like Iran. That path would not only endanger China’s economic gains but also erode the fragile trust that allows global trade to flourish.

Beijing lays out its views on world order at Chinese Foreign Minister’s press conference

The challenge is to reset the China-US relationship. Constructive engagement is required. The US must be clear about its interests, and China must seriously consider accommodating them, especially when they feel intrusive. This is not about surrendering sovereignty and ambitions. It is about recognising interdependence.

SCMP Plus is a new premium news platform that gives you an
all-inclusive edge to stay ahead on China news.
To access our exclusive content you’ll need to subscribe.
Already a subscriber?
LOG IN

China’s prosperity is tied to a system that requires compromise. The US, on the other hand, must avoid treating China simply as a threat. It must acknowledge China’s contributions and understand it is imperative that they find ways to compete peacefully.

History teaches us that ignoring aggression leads to war, and dismantling governments without rebuilding authority leads to chaos. China has so far avoided those mistakes. It should continue to do so by resisting entanglement with Iran and keeping its focus not only on Taiwan but also on the global system that sustains its rise.

The US must learn from its failures and craft a China policy that is more than hostility. Together, they must preserve the fragile peace that allows science, trade and progress to flourish. China must choose: stabiliser or spoiler. Its decision will shape not only its future but that of the world.

Dong Lei
Dong Lei is an independent observer of Chinese politics and history, with a particular interest in China’s evolving role in global affairs. He is currently writing a book on international relations, examining China’s strategic posture and its impact on the world order.
related topics

No comments:

Post a Comment