Turkey’s Erdogan must reform
or resign
By Mort
Abramowitz and Eric Edelman March 10 at 7:33 PM
Mort
Abramowitz and Eric Edelman, both former U.S. ambassadors to Turkey, co-chair
the Bipartisan Policy Center’s Turkey Initiative. Abramowitz is a senior fellow
at the Century Foundation and Edelman is a practitioner-in-residence at the
Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies.
Under the
leadership of President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Turkey has steadily descended
into authoritarianism and instability. The recent government seizure of one of
the main opposition media groups, including Turkey’s highest-circulation newspaper, is only
the latest demonstration of how Erdogan has betrayed his county’s potential.
When Erdogan
and his Justice and Development Party (AK Party) took power in 2003, they
strengthened the Turkish economy and improved Turkey’s relations with its
neighbors. The AK Party pursued European Union membership, ended military
domination over Turkish politics and tried to find a peaceful solution to the
country’s long-standing Kurdish problem.
By 2012,
Erdogan could confidently declare, “We have a bright future.” After nearly a decade
of political progress, economic growth and growing international approval, he
could dare to promise that by 2023, the centenary of the republic, Turkey would
be “one of the greatest powers of its region and the world.”
Today, Turkey’s
future looks much bleaker. Rather than greatness, Erdogan has steered it toward
authoritarianism, economic slowdown and civil war.
Clearly,
democracy cannot flourish under Erdogan now. The transformative reforms the AK
Party originally promised have given way to systematic abuses of basic freedoms
and legal rights. The AK Party’s heralded attempt to hold the military
accountable for its undemocratic behavior was a show trial in which
manufactured evidence served to implicate political opponents. Early
interference with the media — slapping an opposition media conglomerate with a $2.5 billion tax fine in 2009 and forcing a
newspaper to fire a critical columnist in 2007 — was just an
indication of the AK Party’s now far-reaching efforts to muzzle the press,
whether by jailing journalists or authorizing government takeovers of critical
outlets. Nor has civil society been spared Erdogan’s heavy-handed tactics: In
2013, protests against the government in Istanbul’s Gezi Park were met with deadly police violence.
Indeed,
recent developments in Turkey bring to mind frightening cliches and dark
moments of 20th-century totalitarianism. An AK Party parliamentarian led a mob to attack the
offices of a newspaper lambasted by Erdogan just days prior. Several AK Party
members, including former president Abdullah Gul, have been removed from an
official online list of the party’s founding members. Among thousands of
others, a 13-year-old boy was arrested for insulting
Erdogan, and a woman who did likewise was denounced in the courts by
her own husband. Tens of thousands of children, including religious
minorities, have been forcibly sent to Islamic schools or subjected to
mandatory Islamic religious education. Now, as Erdogan seeks to transform the
Turkish constitution to entrench his power as president, such abuses will
likely become the norm.
Authoritarian
leaders usually justify their rule by insisting they are bringing their
citizens stability and prosperity. In Turkey, Erdogan’s policies are putting
both of these further beyond the people’s reach. After supporting and arming extremist groups in the
Syrian conflict, Turkey is now experiencing dangerous blowback from the
terrorism it helped stoke. Bombings in Istanbul and Ankara have created
shocking scenes of carnage. Yet Turkey continues to insist that Syrian Kurdish
groups — not the Islamic State or Jabhat al-Nusra — are the greatest threat in Syria.
The
repercussions of this authoritarianism and instability are taking their toll on
Turkey’s tourism industry and scaring away foreign investors, leaving many
economists worried about the future of the Turkish economy. In 2008, the
Turkish lira was almost equal to the dollar. Now the exchange rate is 3-to-1 . And while Turkey’s efforts to care
for millions of Syrian refugees are truly impressive, they tax the Turkish
economy in ways that ordinary citizens are all too aware of.
Worse, the collapse of
negotiations between the AK Party and the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) last
year has reignited a military conflict that many hoped Turkey was on the verge
of resolving. The PKK is a terrorist group with a track record of violence that
hardly makes it an ideal partner for peace, but the Turkish people nonetheless
have the right to hold their government accountable for the negotiations’
failure. Now, Turkish soldiers and civilians continue to die in a worsening
conflict, and the government has no realistic plan for stopping or winning it.
The horrible bombing in Ankara on Feb. 17, carried out by
a PKK splinter faction,
portends a spread of violence that could throw Turkey back into the civil war
that decimated the country in the 1970s and ’80s.
We continue
to believe that a strong, stable and democratic Turkey is both possible and
essential. But this requires a government committed to these goals and intent
on achieving them. If Erdogan still wants to deliver a brighter future for his country,
he has to reform or resign.
No comments:
Post a Comment