CNN : Emotions run high in Turkey amid questions over state response to deadly quake By Lauren Said-Moorhouse, Isil Sariyuce, Zeena Saifi and Reyhan Baysan, CNN Published 3:13 PM EST, Wed February 8, 2023

 Emotions run high in Turkey amid questions over state response to deadly quake

By Lauren Said-Moorhouse, Isil Sariyuce, Zeena Saifi and Reyhan Baysan, CNN

Published 3:13 PM EST, Wed February 8, 2023

CNN

 — 

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has admitted to “shortcomings” as it emerged his government restricted Twitter access amid growing anger over the state’s response to the massive earthquake earlier this week, which is now known to have killed more than 11,000 people.

Two days after the quake hit Turkey’s Gaziantep province near the Syrian border, rescuers are racing against the clock through freezing conditions in a frantic scramble to pull survivors from the debris. As questions emerge over the country’s preparedness, the latest estimates from the World Health Organization said up to 23 million people could be affected by the disaster.

Huge piles of rubble and wreckage litter streets in Gaziantep where residential buildings and properties once stood. As the desperate search for survivors continues, emergency responders have periodically called for silence from those in the immediate vicinity and for heavy machinery to briefly still while rescuers check for signs of life from trapped residents.

The official response has seen Erdogan declare a state of emergency for the next three months in 10 provinces. The country’s disaster management agency has deployed search and rescue teams to badly-hit areas and the health minister announced field hospitals had been set up.

A girl sits near the site of a collapsed building following an earthquake in Kahramanmaras, Turkey February 8, 2023. REUTERS/Dilara Senkaya

Hope and despair as rescuers search for survivors in quake-hit city of Kahramanmaras

Speaking as he visited several earthquake disaster zones Wednesday, Erdogan vowed to take “every necessary step” and unite the state and nation so that “we will not leave any citizen unattended.”

Earlier in the day, the president had acknowledged public concern over the government’s response, admitting the state initially “had some problems” at airports and on roads, but insisting the situation was now “under control.”

Erdogan also angrily pushed back against “some dishonest people” for “falsely slandering” his government’s quake response, saying the moment called for unity and that “in such a period, I cannot tolerate the viciously negative campaigns for the sake of simple political interests.”

He continued: “No doubt our job was not easy. The difficulty of weather conditions added to the magnitude and prevalence of the destruction caused by this earthquake, which was felt in an area of ​​500 kilometers in which approximately 13.5 million people live. Despite this, we mobilized all the resources of the state and the nation and directed them to the disaster area.”

“Of course there are shortcomings. The conditions are obvious. It is not possible to be prepared for such a disaster. We will not leave any of our citizens uncared for.”

Sister shields sibling from dust during 36-hour wait for help after quake

Erdogan’s remarks come amid growing frustration from the public after reports emerged of entire towns in the country’s north flattened by the powerful tremblors. Amid the discontent, access to Twitter was restricted in Turkey.

Network monitoring firm NetBlocks said Wednesday that traffic filtering had been applied at the internet service provider level that was preventing Twitter users from reaching the social media site. The report coincided with user claims that Twitter was inaccessible in the country.

“Widespread reports of Twitter being throttled in Turkey,” tweeted Zeynep Tufekci, a professor at Columbia University who was born in Istanbul and a longtime scholar of large-scale social media usage. Tufekci added that some Twitter users had been expressing “increasing dissatisfaction” with Turkey’s response effort.

CNN has reached out to Twitter for comment.

Turkey’s Information and Communication Technologies Authority oversees internet use in the country, and has not acknowledged the reported restriction or provided any reasoning for the curbs some users have seen. However, Turkish police have announced that multiple people have been detained or arrested following “provocative posts” about the quake on social platforms and websites “that want to abuse our citizens” have been shuttered.

Public response divided

Turkey is a country familiar with earthquakes given its location over several tectonic plates, but disasters like Monday are not common.

This week’s magnitude 7.8 quake was one of the most powerful to rock the region in the last century. An equally-strong 7.8 magnitude quake hit the east of the country in 1939, which resulted in more than 30,000 deaths, according to the United States Geological Survey.

In the wake of a separate massive quake in 1999 – which killed more than 17,000 people – the Turkish state introduced a so-called “earthquake tax” to provide support as a result of the economic losses from the disaster.

The tax – called the “special communications tax” by authorities – was one of the six taxes introduced after that catastrophe. It was initially introduced as a temporary measure, but subsequently became a permanent levy. Charged for the past 24 years, local tax expert Ozan Bingol estimates that the state has collected around 88 billion Turkish lira as a result.

The largest amount was collected last year, totaling 9.3 billion lira (approximately half a billion dollars). It is unclear how the tax has been spent – whether some of it has been used for reinforcing buildings or for earthquake preparations – which have added to public frustration.

The Turkish Ministry of Treasury and Finance lists the tax as “general budget revenue” but the government doesn’t specify exactly how the collected money has been used. Inclusion in the “general budget” means it’s expected to be used as a “service to people” for projects like building roads, bridges, hospitals and other general payments.

In Gaziantep, a stronghold for the ruling AKP party, there appeared to be a generational split among residents over the state’s handling of the disaster.

Kadir Suliman, a 23-year-old student, told CNN: “The state came here as soon as they could and is working 24/7 to help everyone. I criticize the people who criticize the government. They should just keep to themselves.”

Another student, Mustafa Yldrem, also 23, pushed back against criticism, questioning what more could have done in the face of such a widespread catastrophe.

“There have been 10 earthquakes in 10 different cities across the country. What more can the government do? The state is sending updates via text messages to all citizens about the safety of their areas. They inform us if buildings were inspected by the state and if they were cleared for safety. They opened up spaces of refuge, mosques, schools, etc and made sure they were heated. All for free.”

The historic Yeni Mosque is damaged in Malatya. 

People search through rubble at a destroyed building in Diyarbakir.

Rescue workers carry <a href="https://www.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/turkey-syria-earthquake-updates-2-8-23-intl/h_bd774ec75c5663ab848e61d684bc914c" target="_blank">8-year-old survivor</a> Yigit Cakmak from the site of a collapsed building in Hatay, Turkey, on Wednesday, February 8. It was more than 50 hours after the earthquake struck. The boy was passed from rescuer to rescuer until he was finally in the arms of his mother who was waiting at the site.

Rescue workers carry 8-year-old survivor Yigit Cakmak from the site of a collapsed building in Hatay, Turkey, on Wednesday, February 8. It was more than 50 hours after the earthquake struck. The boy was passed from rescuer to rescuer until he was finally in the arms of his mother who was waiting at the site.

Burak Kara/Getty Images

People work at the site of a collapsed building in Kahramanmaraş, Turkey, on February 8.

Volunteers distribute aid to people in Antakya, Turkey, on February 8.

A firefighter works at the Turkish port of Iskenderun, where a fire broke out in the aftermath of the quake.

Mahmut Salman, 16, is rescued in Hatay, Turkey, on February 8.

A person walks among tents in Kahramanmaraş on February 8.

The foot of a dead child is seen under a destroyed building in Kahramanmaraş on February 8.

A firefighter searches for people in the rubble of a destroyed building in Gaziantep, Turkey, on February 8.

Search-and-rescue efforts continue in Hatay on Tuesday, February 7.

Search-and-rescue teams carry 2-year-old Vafe Sabha, who was pulled from rubble along with her mother in Hatay on February 8.

Volunteers share an emotional moment as they take part in a rescue operation in Hatay on February 8.

Mesut Hancer <a href="https://www.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/turkey-syria-earthquake-updates-2-7-23-intl/h_abe9973d81144098a7fe382f62b13d94" target="_blank">holds the hand</a> of his 15-year-old daughter Irmak, who died in Kahramanmaraş.

Smoke billows from the port in Iskenderun as emergency workers continue rescue efforts on February 7.

Two people embrace near the rubble of a collapsed building in Hatay on February 7.

Emergency workers search for people in a destroyed building in Adana, Turkey, on February 7.

A baby girl who was <a href="https://www.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/turkey-syria-earthquake-updates-2-7-23-intl/h_c188508ebd6a0fb641e2c682af0e9ba2" target="_blank">reportedly rescued from the rubble of her family's home</a> receives treatment at a hospital in Afrin, Syria, on February 7. Her umbilical cord was still attached to her mother when she was found, <a href="https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20230207-syria-newborn-pulled-alive-from-quake-rubble" target="_blank" target="_blank">a relative told Agence France-Presse</a>. Her mother is believed to have died after giving birth.

People in the Syrian village of Hajji Iskandar mourn over the bodies of a family and close neighbors who were killed in the quake.

People wait for news of their loved ones, who were believed to be trapped under a collapsed building in Hatay on February 7.

Destruction is seen in Hatay's city center on February 7.

Police carry a child who was rescued from rubble in Hatay on February 7.

A man reacts in Jandaris, Syria, on February 7.

Search-and-rescue efforts continue through cold weather conditions in Malatya, Turkey, on February 7. 

People try to identify the bodies of victims outside a hospital in Aleppo, Syria, on Monday, February 6.

A woman mourns for a dead relative in Turkey's Hatay province on February 7.

A rescue team works at a collapsed building in Osmaniye, Turkey, on February 6.

A child looks out from a bus where people were sleeping in Antakya on February 6.

People gather around a bonfire in Kahramanmaraş.

Search-and-rescue personnel work at a collapsed building in Malatya on February 6.

Residents rescue an injured girl from the rubble of a collapsed building in Jandaris on February 6.

Rescuers work in Antakya on February 6.

A man weeps as he carries the body of his infant son who was killed in Jandaris.

This aerial photo shows damage in Hatay on February 6.

A fire burns near overturned containers in Hatay.

People wait as rescue operations take place in Diyarbakir, Turkey, on February 6.

People search a destroyed building in Adana on February 6.

This aerial photo shows a damaged building in Adana.

Quake victims are treated in the emergency ward of the Bab al-Hawa hospital in Syria's Idlib province.

A person climbs through the rubble of a collapsed building in Hatay.

A man reacts as people search for survivors in Diyarbakir.

A person is rescued from a destroyed building in Gaziantep.

Residents search through collapsed buildings in the Syrian village of Besnia.

A building is destroyed in Adana.

A woman reacts as rescuers search for survivors in Adana.

Civilians and members of the Syria Civil Defense try to save people trapped beneath a destroyed building in Idlib.

The quake damaged Turkey's <a href="http://www.cnn.com/travel/article/gaziantep-castle-destroyed-turkey-earthquake/index.html" target="_blank">Gaziantep Castle</a>.

Search-and-rescue efforts continue at the site of a destroyed building in Diyarbakir.

A cat is tended to after being rescued from the rubble in Diyarbakir.

Emergency workers rescue a child from a collapsed building in Diyarbakir.

People work through the rubble of a collapsed building in Diyarbakir.

People search for survivors in Diyarbakir.

Members of the Syria Civil Defense, aka the White Helmets, retrieve an injured man from the rubble of a collapsed building in Azaz, Syria.

People search a destroyed building in Diyarbakir.

People look on at the site of a destroyed building in Adana. 

People search under the rubble of a building that collapsed in Azmarin, Syria.

People warm themselves outside of earthquake-affected areas in Aleppo on February 6.

The historic Yeni Mosque is damaged in Malatya. 

People search through rubble at a destroyed building in Diyarbakir.

Rescue workers carry <a href="https://www.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/turkey-syria-earthquake-updates-2-8-23-intl/h_bd774ec75c5663ab848e61d684bc914c" target="_blank">8-year-old survivor</a> 

Yigit Cakmak from the site of a collapsed building in Hatay, Turkey, on Wednesday, February 8. It was more than 50 hours after the earthquake struck. The boy was passed from rescuer to rescuer until he was finally in the arms of his mother who was waiting at the site.

People work at the site of a collapsed building in Kahramanmaraş, Turkey, on February 8.

In photos: Deadly quake strikes Turkey and Syria

1 of 57

PrevNext

But Aziz Karabekmez, a 68-year-old retired electrician, denounced the government’s efforts and accused the state of “taking money from us for nothing.”

“The country is prone to earthquakes, they should be protecting our neighborhoods,” Karabekmez said. “The people in the front line sifting through the rubble are the Kazakhs and foreign volunteers, not the Turks. They don’t know how to do work. Why?”

Likewise, 70-year-old retired engineer Mehmet Ali Karabekmez, also shared his frustration, saying “they swallow our money.”

Karabekmez added: “If there was a benefit to the money they take from us, would we be in this position? The work from the Turkish officials has been very slow. Every time a building shakes a bit, you see them run away. They have no experience.”

Widespread destruction sparks questions

More than 5,700 buildings in Turkey have collapsed, according to the country’s disaster agency. With so much damage, both in Turkey and neighboring Syria, many are starting to ask about the role that building infrastructure might have played in the tragedy.

“The thing that strikes mostly are the type of collapses – what we call the pancake collapse – which is the type of collapse that we engineers don’t like to see,” said Mustafa Erdik, a professor of earthquake engineering at Bogazici University in Istanbul. “In such collapses, it’s difficult – as you can see – and a very tragic to save lives. It makes the operation of the search and rescue teams very difficult.”

Erdik told CNN the images of extensive ruins in the quake’s aftermath indicated “that there are highly variable qualities of designs and construction.” He said that the type of post-earthquake structural failures are usually partial collapses. “Total collapses are something you always try to avoid both in codes and the actual design,” he added.

USGS structural engineer Kishor Jaiswal told CNN Tuesday that Turkey has experienced significant earthquakes in the past, including a quake in 1999 which left thousands dead.

Jaiswal said many parts of Turkey have been designated as very high seismic hazard zones and, as such, building regulations in the region mean construction projects should withstand these types of events and in most cases avoid catastrophic collapses – if done properly.

But not all buildings have been built according to the modern Turkish seismic standard, Jaiswal said. Deficiencies in the design and construction, especially in older buildings, mean that many buildings could not handle the severity of the shocks.

“If you are not designing these structures for the seismic intensity that they may face in their design life, these structures may not perform well,” said Jaiswal.

Erdik also said he believed many of the buildings that have collapsed were likely “built pre-1999.” He added there also would have been instances where some buildings didn’t conform to code.

“The codes are very modern in Turkey, very similar to US codes. But again, the codes conformity is an issue that we’ve tried to tackle with legal and administrative procedures. We have the permits from municipalities and controls for design, controls for construction. But then again, there are things that are lacking.”

CNN’s Hande Atay Alam and Brian Fung also contributed to this report.